CNIL sanctions in prospecting: 3 decisions to know (and how to avoid them)
In brief
- Three public CNIL penalties highlight the most frequent errors in prospecting: unlawful data collection (Kaspr, €240,000), improperly obtained consent (Accor, €600,000), deceptive forms with inadequate proof (SoLocal MS, €900,000). Common factor: consent poorly obtained or impossible to prove.
Overview of the 3 penalties
| Organisation | Amount | Date | Main breach |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kaspr | €240,000 | 5 December 2024 | Data collection by scraping, excessive retention period |
| Accor | €600,000 | 3 August 2022 | Pre-ticked newsletter consent box |
| SoLocal MS | €900,000 | 15 May 2025 | Deceptive forms (dark patterns), inadequate proof |
1. Kaspr (€240,000) — unlawful data collection
What was criticised: data enrichment carried out from LinkedIn profiles with limited visibility (scraping), excessive retention period and insufficient management of access rights.
The lesson: the origin of your data matters as much as its use. Before integrating a database — purchased, enriched or scraped — verify its lawfulness and document its source. For prospecting, a 'convenient' but unlawful database is a ticking time bomb.
2. Accor (€600,000) — improperly obtained consent
What was criticised: a pre-ticked newsletter consent box, combined with inadequate information and right to object. Consent was therefore not valid.
The lesson: consent must result from a positive action. No pre-ticked boxes, no inactivity deemed as agreement. Each purpose must be clearly presented, with an option to refuse as simple as accepting. See B2C prospecting and GDPR.
3. SoLocal MS (€900,000) — dark patterns and proof
What was criticised: deceptive competition forms (dark patterns) and the inability to prove valid consent for prospected individuals.
The lesson: beyond collection, it's the proof that is lacking. Article 7.1 of the GDPR requires demonstration, contact by contact, that consent was indeed given — with the date, the form and the information displayed.
The common thread: collect AND prove
These three decisions converge towards the same message: prospecting compliance is not only determined at the time of sending, but before (lawfulness, consent) and after (proof, respect of rights).
Three reflexes are sufficient to avoid the majority of these situations:
- Verify the origin of each piece of data and its legal basis.
- Obtain valid consent — freely given, specific, informed, unambiguous — without dark patterns.
- Keep proof on an individualised basis.
Compliance: a constraint or an opportunity?
Viewed as a constraint, GDPR slows down prospecting: self-censorship, abandoned channels, fear of audits. When mastered, it becomes a commercial opportunity: all channels open lawfully, better deliverability, clean data and teams that sell instead of 'fixing'. Companies that structure their compliance also display a trust argument with their clients.
Sources: CNIL decisions — Kaspr (5 Dec. 2024), Accor (3 Aug. 2022), SoLocal MS (15 May 2025); GDPR art. 7.1.
Take action
Document the lawfulness of your data and prepare for a potential CNIL audit: assess your compliance with Data Comply One.
Measure my GDPR score →Request a demo