Email open rate tracking: is consent now required?

Email open rate tracking: is consent now required?

In brief

  • It depends on the purpose. Measuring open rate to optimise your campaigns (personalise, adjust frequency/channel) requires consent since the CNIL recommendation of 12 March 2026. Using it strictly for deliverability (cleaning up inactive contacts) is exempt, subject to minimisation conditions.

Why open rate is subject to the GDPR

Open rate is not an 'anonymous' statistic: it relies on a tracking pixel, an invisible image loaded when the email is opened. This loading triggers a reading of information on the recipient's device, which brings the practice within the scope of Article 82 of the French Data Protection Act.

In short: without a pixel, no open rate—and as soon as there is a pixel, the question of consent arises. For the full framework, see CNIL tracking pixels 2026.

The dividing line: deliverability vs marketing

The CNIL distinguishes two uses of the same indicator.

Use of open rateConsentExample
Optimise performance of campaignsRequiredPersonalise content, adjust frequency/channel, A/B testing
Profile to target elsewhereRequiredRetarget on websites, apps, other channels
Detect fraud (mass opens)RequiredCompetition anti-fraud
Strict deliverabilityExemptClean up inactive contacts, stop/adapt sends

The golden rule: it is the purpose that determines it, not the technology.

How to stay within the 'deliverability' exemption

To benefit from the exemption, the CNIL requires compliance with the principle of minimisation (Article 5.1.b of the GDPR):

  • limit use to what is strictly necessary to adapt the frequency or stop sending to inactive recipients;
  • retain, in principle, only the date of the last open (by day, without the time), updated at each open, with deletion of the previous one;
  • the exemption also applies for assessing the communication channel or demonstrating compliance with a legal obligation (e.g. transactional emails).

As soon as you go beyond this scope—measuring to optimise, personalise, profile—you switch to the consent regime.

What to do in practice before 14 July 2026?

  1. Map your emailing tools and active pixels.
  2. Qualify each purpose: deliverability (exempt) or optimisation (consent).
  3. Obtain consent from the point of address collection for marketing uses.
  4. Facilitate withdrawal via a link in the footer.
  5. Prove consent on an individual basis.

If your tool does not allow you to distinguish these uses or disable marketing pixels, it may be time to consider another provider.

Sources: CNIL, tracking pixels recommendation (12 March 2026), points 3.1 and 3.2; GDPR art. 5.1.b.

Take action

Qualify your purposes and prove your consents: assess your compliance for free with Data Comply One.

Measure my GDPR score →Request a demo

Frequently asked questions

Can I still measure my open rate without consent?

Yes, only if it strictly serves deliverability (cleaning up inactive contacts, adjusting frequency) and you only retain the date of last open.

Does A/B testing on open rate require consent?

Yes: optimising campaign performance falls under marketing purposes subject to consent.

What data can I retain under deliverability?

In principle, only the date (by day) of the last known open, updated at each new open.